Material Selection & Maintenance Guide - Crispins Shoes

Choosing the right material matters more than most people think. It changes how the shoes break in, how they cope with rain, how easy they are to clean, and how they look after a year of wear. This guide covers the materials you’ll see most at Crispins, how to pick between them, and the simple care routines that keep favourites going for longer. We’ll use the same plain phrases people search for, like how to clean suede shoes or how to stretch leather shoes, so you can find what you need fast.

Types of materials used in shoes

Smooth calf/nappa leather

Soft, fine‑grained leather that polishes well and moulds to the foot. It’s great for smart boots, loafers, courts and everyday office wear.

Grained/tumbled leather

Textured surface that’s tougher and hides scuffs. This one is a good pick for commuting and damp pavements.

Suede

Velvety nap with rich colour. It looks special; needs a little protection and a brush now and then.

Nubuck

Like a very fine suede - silky, matte, premium. Be sure to treat them gently.

Patent leather

High‑gloss finish that’s instantly dressy. Best for events; store so it doesn’t touch other shoes.

Fabric/textile uppers

From canvas to technical knits. Usually light, breathable and summer‑friendly.

(You’ll also see occasional stretch suedes and special finishes; treat them like the closest match above and go lightly with cleaners.)

Material selection and what to look for

  • Your week, not just the look. Daily city walking or rain? Go grained leather or protected suede on rubber soles. Desk‑to‑dinner? Smooth calf or refined suede works.
  • Fit quirks. For wider forefeet or bunions, soft nappa or stretch suede feels kinder across the joint.
  • Soles change the story. Leather soles are sleek; rubber/TPU gives grip and a bit of bounce. You can add a thin rubber protector to leather soles without spoiling the line.
  • Colour & care. Darker shades hide scuffs; light suede looks fantastic but needs quick brushing after wear.
  • Break‑in. Soft leathers mould in a few outings. Stiffer leathers need short wears at home first (see how to soften leather shoes).

Two‑minute shop test: walk a few steps and flex. If the upper pinches the little toe or bites the big toe knuckle straight away, it won’t “settle” enough to fix that.

Care and maintenance tips

Daily quick routine (30–60 seconds)

  • Brush off dust/grit. Suede/nubuck: suede brush; leather: soft brush/cloth.
  • Use shoe trees (cedar if you have them) or stuff the toes with paper.
  • Let shoes dry in fresh air, away from radiators.

Weekly-ish

  • Leather shoes: Wipe clean, then a small amount of neutral or colour‑matched cream polish. Buff.
  • Suede shoes: Once dry, brush the nap back up; top up a suede protector if they’ve seen rain.
  • Fabric shoes: Soft brush; spot‑clean

Seasonally/after hard wear

  • Leather: Tiny bit of conditioner, then cream polish. Less is more.
  • Suede/Nubuck: Clean with a suede/nubuck cleaner; let dry fully; re‑protect.
  • Soles & heels: Replace heel tips before they’re gone; consider a thin rubber protector on leather soles.

Cleaning steps by material (quick reference)

Material 1) Remove dirt 3) Clean 4) Dry 5) Protect / Finish
Leather (smooth / nappa) Soft brush/cloth Damp wipe; tiny drop of mild soap if needed Air-dry away from heat Pea-sized cream polish; buff. Light conditioner occasionally
Grained / tumbled leather Soft brush (work into grain) Damp wipe Air-dry Light cream if scuffed; buff
Suede Let mud dry; suede brush Suede block/eraser on shiny spots Air-dry stuffed with paper Mist with suede protector once fully dry
Nubuck Nubuck/suede brush Nubuck cleaner (sparingly) Air-dry Nubuck protector; gentle brush to restore feel
Patent leather Soft cloth Wipe—no soaps needed Air-dry Patent cleaner for shine; store in separate bags
Fabric / textile Soft brush Spot-clean with mild soap Air-dry stuffed with paper Fabric-safe protector spray
White leather / fabric Soft brush/cloth Mild soap on a clean white cloth Air-dry Neutral/white cream for leather; protector for fabric

 

Comparison and use‑case scenarios 

  • Office to dinner: Smooth calf/nappa; leather sole (or leather + thin rubber protector). Polishes to a glow.
  • Commuting/wet pavements: Grained leather or protected suede; rubber/TPU soles for grip.
  • Weekends/casual: Nubuck or fabric with cushioned rubber soles—light and easy.
  • Rain days: Grained leather first; if suede, pre‑spray protector and let dry naturally later.
  • Sensitive spots (bunions/high instep): Stretch suede or soft nappa; round/almond toes.

 

Material Best for Rain-friendly Break-in/Stretch Quick care Maintenance
Smooth calf / nappa Office to dinner, smart pairs Moderate (with polish); add thin rubber sole Break-in: short; Stretch: low–medium Wipe → cream polish → buff Low–medium
Grained / tumbled leather Daily walking, travel Good (with rubber soles) Break-in: short; Stretch: low Brush grain, light cream Low
Suede Smart-casual, events Fair if protected; avoid heavy rain Break-in: short; Stretch: medium Dry brush, block shiny bits, protect Medium
Nubuck Casual-smart Fair if protected Break-in: short; Stretch: medium Nubuck cleaner + protector Medium
Patent leather Occasions Poor; wipe dry if wet Break-in: short; Stretch: very low Wipe + patent cleaner; separate storage Low
Fabric / textile Summer, travel Varies; dries fast Break-in: minimal; Stretch: low–medium (knit) Soft brush, mild-soap spot-clean Low
Stretch suede Comfort for sensitive spots Fair if protected Break-in: minimal; Stretch: medium–high Gentle brush, light protector Medium

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Leather Shoes

What’s the difference between full-grain, top-grain, and corrected leather?

Full-grain keeps the natural surface and ages best; top-grain is lightly sanded and finished for a smoother look; corrected leather has a heavier finish to hide marks and looks very uniform.

Are leather shoes waterproof?

They’re water-resistant, not waterproof. Cream polish helps; a neutral wax adds a touch more. Prolonged rain still finds a way in, so pair with rubber soles where possible.

How to clean leather shoes?

Brush off dirt, wipe with a damp cloth, let dry, then a pea-sized amount of cream polish. Buff. If very dry, use a tiny bit of conditioner first.

Do leather shoes stretch? How to stretch leather shoes?

A little. Wear them briefly with medium socks, or use a shoe stretcher with spot plugs. A cobbler can stretch precisely. Don’t soak them.

How to soften leather shoes?

Short wears around the house, flexible trees between wears, and (sparingly) a light conditioner. Heavy oils make leather floppy and can stain.

How long do leather shoes last?

Years with light, regular care - heel tips, the odd sole protector, and sensible drying.

Suede Shoes

What is suede, and how is it different from leather?

Suede is leather - the reverse side is buffed to a soft nap. Same base material; different finish and care.

Can I wear suede shoes in the rain?

Light rain is fine if you’ve used a protector. For heavy rain, pick grained leather or change shoes at the venue.

How to clean suede shoes?

Let mud dry, brush gently with a suede brush, use a suede block/eraser on shiny spots, then brush again. Re-apply a protector when fully dry.

Can you put suede shoes in the washing machine?

No, machine washing flattens the nap, warps the shape, and makes a mess of the finish.

Why do suede shoes get marks so easily?

The open nap grabs dust and oils. A quick brush after wear and a good protector keep them fresher.

Can suede shoes be repaired if damaged?

Small scuffs and shiny patches often respond to a block and brush. Deep stains or dye transfer - see a specialist.

Can you dye suede shoes?

Yes, but it’s a specialist job. Home kits exist, but colour can be patchy. Worth using a pro on favourites.

Do suede shoes stretch? How to stretch suede shoes?

They relax a touch more than smooth leather. Use a stretcher or short wears with thicker socks, but don’t rely on big stretch to solve a tight fit.

Fabric Shoes

Are fabric shoes durable?

Good ones are - canvas and technical knits hold up well, though they don’t love kerbs or winter salt.

Can I wash fabric shoes in the washing machine?

Only if the maker allows it. If yes, use a gentle cycle, pop them in a laundry bag, remove laces/insoles, then air-dry stuffed with paper. Never tumble-dry.

Are fabric shoes good for hot weather?

Yes, light and breathable, often ideal for travel.

Do fabric shoes offer support like leather ones?

Support comes from the last and construction, not just material. Many fabric shoes are very supportive - walk around and check how they feel.

How do I protect fabric shoes from stains?

Use a fabric-safe protector before first wear and top up monthly. Spot-clean spills quickly with mild soap.

Do fabric shoes stretch with wear?

A little … knits more than canvas. If tight on day one, size up rather than relying on stretch.

Conclusion

Choose the material that fits your lifestyle. Go with leather shoes for polish and longevity, maybe suede shoes for rich texture, or fabric shoes for light, breathable days. Give your shoes a minute of care when you take them off. Swap heel tips before they vanish, add a rubber protector if you’re on pavements all week, and keep pairs away from heat. Do that and you’ll get years, not months, from the styles you love. Not sure which way to go? Tell us how you’ll wear them and we’ll suggest the right material-and-sole combo for you.